Controversial referee decisions mar Arsenal’s narrow victory over Manchester United

Abdullateef Fowewe

In a fiercely contested Premier League opener at Old Trafford on Sunday, Arsenal edged Manchester United 1-0 in a match shadowed by controversial refereeing that many believe influenced the outcome.

The game’s only goal came early, when Riccardo Calafiori capitalised on a goalkeeping error, but throughout the match, there were several decisions by the referee that sparked debate among fans and pundits alike.

Manchester United, under Ruben Amorim, started the campaign with high hopes, boasting the arrival of new attacking players such as Matheus Cunha, Bryan Mbeumo, and Benjamin Sesko.

Despite their renewed firepower and several close chances, including a shot rattling the post and goalkeeper David Raya pulling off spectacular saves, United struggled to find the breakthrough.

Arsenal, managed by Mikel Arteta, showed experience and grit in maintaining their slim lead.

While their performance was not their best, and they managed only a handful of shots on target late in the game, the Gunners managed to hold off United’s pressure until the final whistle.

What added fuel to the controversy were referee calls that United supporters argue went against their side, influencing critical moments and potentially altering the game’s rhythm.

Calls regarding fouls, offside positions, and penalty appeals were hotly debated, leaving many fans feeling aggrieved that the home side did not get a fair chance.

Despite the loss, there were encouraging signs for Manchester United, with improved organisation and a spirited second-half display.

However, the shadow of the contentious officiating left a sour taste, amplifying the frustration around United’s ongoing struggles to reclaim their former dominance.

Arsenal’s victory, though narrow and contested, continues their run of consistent finishes near the top of the Premier League—though the team still seeks to convert such wins into silverware.